Homestar Runner Wiki Forum

Things to consider:
*They sometimes reveal true names of certain characters (e.g. The Cleric) and objects (e.g. Monosodium Dreams)
*They seldom show what a character said (e.g. PbTC Coach Z-dactyl saying, "I look at to fly!" in Summer Short Shorts, Regenerated Head Bad saying something unintellegible in Disconnected)
*Pointing out things that just aren't there (e.g. TBC say there's Manhunter of New York in the diskette containter instead of BAAL in Different Town)
*And any other advantages/disadvantages you might know about.

Although I've always wondered how TBC can quickly come up with stuff and still be funny.

_________________

I really enjoy the commentaries. I can't wait to hear the commentary to fan club.

_________________
"Explain to me how drowning them would not ruin their date."

Without question.

_________________


"Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure
about the former" - Albert Einstein

The only thing wrong with the commentaries is the fact they don't appear for every single Homestar Runner toon ever made in the site's history (how the crap does decaf coffee give Strong Sad a caffiene buzz?)

_________________
Making sense is not part of my mission plan, soldier!
http://www.youtube.com/dsneybuf

I just added the "Neutral Idea" option in case anybody thinks the commentaries are somewhere in between.

I can't think of a reason why they'd be bad. Can you come up with an example?

_________________

Kind of off topic: Where did you get that picture

On topic: Very good idea

I have no .

_________________

Seeing that no one can think of anything wrong with what's in a commentary, I've changed the choices around so they're all in the positive side and so we can see how "good" the commentaries are.