DukeNuke wrote:
I heard that god sees the past, the present, and the future as one. Like we can see depth, width and height at the same time, he sees the past, present and future all at the same time. So if he's also all-knowing and all-mighty, why has he made the world like it is?
I know you're gonna say he gave people free will, and such, but I can't see why that would matter, seeing as he know what will happen etc.
Say you give a knife to a child, and how to hold it and why and it could hurt itself etc. You know the child will ignore what you told it and hurt itself anyway with the knife. And the child does indeed hurt itself. Sure, you didn't hurt the child. You told it how it should have done. It hurt itself, and you're technically not responsible. But you gave the knife to the child, and knew that it would hurt itself, even tough you told it how to hold the knife. You're still indirectly responsible for the child being hurt.
So when god put that forbidden tree with fruit in Eden, he must have known that they would eat it. He must have known that he would tell them not to, but they would anyway, and that he would throw them out afterwards for doing so. But he still put it there. He could have chosen not to, and let them live happily there forever, but he didn't. He put it there, waited for them to eat it, and then threw them out. No matter how I look at it, I can't help but to feel god was responsible for that. In fact, I can't help but to feel that god is responsible for everything in the whole world, seeing as he's known everything that will ever happen, all along, always...
Well, to begin answering your question, I'll first need to establish a premise:
1)The future does not theoretically exist.
If there WAS a future time, and a state in which all things were destined to be, then we would not be in control of what was going to happen, and this cannot be true, for there is a cause and an effect for everything we do. Why don't you just crawl in a corner and sleep for the rest of your life, since you won't change anything anyway? but, that in of itself implies that you are changing the "future" by what you are currently doing. So, the future doesn't theoretically exist, QED.
2)You can't just put "God Can" in front of nonsense; i.e. God can make a triangle with four sides, because that wouldn't be a triangle any longer. The same would thus apply to seeing the future if we accept Premise 1. So, the child would resultantly be fully at fault for the doing of this, QED #2.
:3