Homestar Runner Wiki Forum

Rouge is right. We need to think about this. We don't want to kill another human. We're starting to lose our numbers advantage over the wolves.

_________________

I'm gonna try an evidence summary thing

- Dacheet15

Toothy grin

The Noid won't shut up about him, despite the fact that he's dead.

- Ian

First person to suspect BTG.

Very defensive

- MikeMcG

Accent

- Teff

Black spot on face, leaf thing?

- Exhibit A or Rogue Leader

Alpha, equals A or leader. Although all eight wolves were there, and they were talking about alpha as if he wasn't there, although some of the wolves could have been NPCs.

Uh... I can't think of anything else, remind me.

That's already been solved.


Also, I should point out that Ian's defensiveness is not evidence. No one wants to be lynched, whether they're human or wolf.

_________________

Yeah, I feel Ian is out for now as well. We have nothing credible to lynch him on, because the case against BTG was rather one sided, and pretty much anyone would have voted him out first had they gotten the chance.

_________________
GENGHIS KHAN!!!!!

If I may be a mite self important....

I vote MikeMcG. Most and most obvious clues IMO.

_________________
ATTN: LOWER BOARD USERS HAVE MOVED TO ANOTHER FORUM. COME JOIN THE FUN!

Ace, you're in luck (for now). I have decided to vote for MikeMcG instead.

_________________
Montgomery was the best Allied commander of WWII.



ACCEPT THAT FACT!

I just don't see Mike McG as a bad guy. If someone completely different, say, Ramrod, were playing instead of him, DG could have kept the accent intact to give us more to figure out.

Well, he's the closest person in my mind to someone with a Scottish accent.

_________________
Montgomery was the best Allied commander of WWII.



ACCEPT THAT FACT!

But that doesn't seem very relevant. I'm of Scottish descent; if I were a wolf DG could have used me instead of Mike. This is really throwing us off, like the Alpha thing.

Yeah, and the weird thing is is I am not really seeing any hints in the story yet... It just really seems plot advancing so far. I really don't want to vote for Mike because of what Inverse said, obvious clues. We thought the same for BTG, and look what it got us. I really gotta think before I cast my vote.

_________________
GENGHIS KHAN!!!!!

Might as well make a tally...

IantheGecko: 3 (Homeschool Winner, Dacheet15, Jello B.)
Dacheet15: 2 (IantheGecko, Beardo)
MikeMcG: 2 (Inverse Tiger, Al Capone II)
Homeschool Winner: 1 (buhubs/STupendous7)

_________________

Ian doesn't play off as a wolf. Dacheet is acting suspicious, but I think it's just his poor communication skills. That MikeMcG is of Scottish decent, but I know him pretty well and he has no accent to speak of and I'm sure a couple of the players are of Scottish descent as well.

I'm voting Homeschool. Buhubs knows what he's doing.

Just one quick thing:

How can you honestly think that Ian was the only person suspect BTG? As I've said before, the story made it seem glaring obvious that we should eliminate him, it's not like Ian has some magic gift for deciphering clues here.

_________________

The user does not relfect their personality here. That's been said quite a few times.

That being said, you have evidence going against you. A lot of evidence. Me, I'm going to stop sharing what I know (since I'm dead, sorry guys) and just watch this.

and buhubs certainly does NOT know what he's doing. That's the same kind of logic that got Bettag killed and he was just a human. You guys have to stop pointing the finger at finger-pointers because it's a part of the game. If the humans want to win the game, you guys'll have to use better strategy than that.

_________________

Dead people can't talk noidy...

O.K., I've had just about enough of this 'Don't blame blamers, blame him' kinda stuff, how about we just scroll through everybody?
Then there's no way we can possibly miss a wolf then...

IantheGecko:
Noid, there's no way for sure we don't know that it's not him, other wolves distance themselves from other wolves when suspicion is on them. Now that Ian's on the hot spot, it seems he's more willing to find scape goats then to prove himself forthright, which makes me suspicious just a teensy bit. I just want to get across the message that everyone is guilty until proven innocent. Plus, all the defenses he has attempted have fallen through with others.
Inverse Tiger:
There was something about a tiger having similarities to a wolf? I dunno, I really am trying to scan for possible wolf evidence, but, I don't think Inverse has done anything that's made me nervous.
Rogue Leader:
One of the usernames that passes itself of as an 'Alpha', a head of some sort.
That Cinnamon Thing:

Only makes me a little uneasy, as if trying to put on a face of some sort, but as I'm going to say with a lot of the alive players, don't read to much into it.
......Rock conspiracy?
Exhibit A:
'Alpha' suspect once again here, people.
Einoo T. Spork:
The mayor could also count as an 'Alpha' suspect, but I think what most stands out to me is that he's the one who inspired the 'Dude, it's still night go back to sleep' signature. Considering he was out and about one of those nights, and that he might've tried to put on a viking face.
Capt. Ido Nos:
Ian has also said 'Oh sure, the werewolf escapes in the night, and how he's still so willing to participate in the game, lik he has some role to accomplish. But I'll have to contemplate on this little one.
sci-fi greg:
Just another one of your typical bandwagoners, but still, it partly could mean a wolf, or a reckless and wanting to move it along townie.
Susan:

Wolf escapes in the night strategy, but would you really see it as wolf evidence?

Wolf evidence perhaps? I dunno, comments?
Acekirby:

A human's position can't be too much fun, can it?
Chekt:
Uhh, wolf?


Uhhh... I'm confused about this one.
STupendous7/me:
I don't think I should be evaluatiing myself, I want it left up to other people.
Teff:
Black mark on one's face? Perhaps a fight or duel of some sort's result?
I'mma not sure.
Beardo:

Perrhaps the wolves thought it was voting of some sort, and this is Beardo helping them along to find out who the SEER is and strike?
Dacheet 15:
I'm only gonna say this once, keep your ears peeled and ready, when Homer was killed DG said that the wolves overheard he was the 'SEER'. I read through that story, there were no other wolves hiding behind some obscure bush of some sort, and yet they still overheard, perhaps...the wolves aren't hiding...that they're right in front of homer's face if you know what I mean.
Jello B.:
There's always room for jello! Anyways, uhh...I don't klnow, he had that younger colleague who was the first to die, it's easy access for the wolves, considering they worked together?
Al Capone II:
Al Capone played part of a mafia right? The game mafia is like a spinoff of TWG?
Similarity?
Mike:

That didn't make sense...at all, plus if you can trust the noid then you can't trust Mike, so that's something for you to decide.
Homeschool Winner:
Then again people, you have to use your heads here, if the wolves are planning to kill off the person who accuses too much (a.k.a. IantheGecko), and Homeschool just voted for him, can you really let that pass by you?

Anyways, 8 of those people who I just listed are wolves, I tried best I could, I just hope more than anything we nail a wolf and that our angel doesn't get murdered. So make of it what you will, as for now, DG, I have a feeling there's gonna be a little more time needed vor voting to lynch.

_________________
If I had posted during the time of COVID, COLA woulda called me worse than the virus.

buhubs, Alpha means nothing. It was a random guess by moi.

_________________

For the last freaking time



Plus, you're missing some good evidence there, buhubs.

You guys are dismissing some clues as too blatant, but I think you're forgetting just how blatant the BTG stuff was. I'd read some of the stories again if I were you.

When the Captain said the wolves are smart and Chekt said "Woo, I'm smart", it was a weird simulpost. Chekt was commenting on the story.

Also, Al Capone is not suspicious because of his name, as the wolves were picked randomly.

Imma changin' mah vote to MikeMcG.

_________________

I'm still not seeing a ton of evidence against one certain person, we need to think here. Last time I voted wrong I got accused because of it. I'm not going to make some snap decision this time.


The fact that he has an accent doesn't seem like a lot of evidence. It's one thing.

BTG seemed like he had a lot of evidence against him, and look where it got us.

_________________

Okay, noid, I get it, but for the last time, shut up. You're dead!

I don't think people are listening to your evidence, if they are ignore me, if not, howsa about you take a break from posting here?



I dunno, I just suspect some people more than others, Ian and Homeschool, but a teensy bit of TCT and Beardo.

_________________
If I had posted during the time of COVID, COLA woulda called me worse than the virus.

Buhubs, I really don't see how you can keep on voting for Ian. We have shown that his behavior isn't unusual, and that he wasn't the only one to vote for BTG either. You gotta stop beating this dead horse.

_________________
GENGHIS KHAN!!!!!

And really, STupendous/you is more suspicious than I am! He voted for both Ju Ju & BTG.

Let's keep an eye on these people. I'm changing my vote to STupendous7/buhubs.

_________________

Did I vote for Ian?
Is Homeschool non existant?

.
.
.

Yeah, that's what I thought...

_________________
If I had posted during the time of COVID, COLA woulda called me worse than the virus.

But you keep accusing me, not everyone else.

I'm pretty sure dead people are allowed to comment. So you shut up.

GET BACK TO WORK

_________________

Watch it, both of you.


What he said. There really isn't any logic for voting for Ian, he hasn't had any role in the stories yet.

That being said:


Ju Ju's downfall was a snap decision for all of us, and BTG had some serious evidence against him and almost everyone voted for him. I don't see how voting both of them condemns me to being a wolf.

_________________

'k k.

Would the stuff against BTG be called evidence, though, even if it was proven to be an homage to Little Red Riding Hood? I would more call it red herrings, not evidence, since it only proved he was a human.

_________________

At the time, we thought it was evidence. Of course we know now he was a human, but at the time we thought his demeanor was clear evidence against him. Hindsight is 20/20, but you have to consider what we thought at the time was clear-cut evidence.

_________________

Ah, okay.

get back to work, evrabody.

_________________