Well, I'm at a loss as to how to explain the name hint in this story. It certainly looks like me.... All I can say in my own defense is that Noid did say some of the hints were red herrings.
Since this seems to be my last chance, I will do my best to present a case for who I think is really guilty. Firstly, I decided to find out who all voted for Homeschool. There was very little evidence against him, so as I said, those who did vote for him look suspicious. The voters were eggs, Ju Ju, Stupendous, and DSOTS. Of these four, two had very suspicious looking reasons for voting:
STupendous7 wrote:
Well, I really don't know what to do. I almost want to vote for Homeschool, but I'm a bit afraid to. Meh, might as well. Homeschool I guess. Probably I'm wrong, but I can't be sure. He's the only one.
This looks like Stu is just voting for the sake of voting, which is never a good idea.
Ju Ju Master wrote:
I haven't found anything else, unfortunately.
Since the round ends tonight, though, I'm gonna vote Homeschool. He's got more evidence against him than anyone else right now, I think it's our best bet.
While technically true, Homeschool still had very little evidence. From what I can see, this vote was based on an assumed connection between Homeschool and "Mike Williams", which I don't see at all.
So, I went back through the last te pages of this thread and looked at all of Ju Ju and Stu's posts, to find some corroborating evidence. Here's what I found for Ju Ju:
Ju Ju Master wrote:
sci-fi greg wrote:
Yeah mike is definently a wolf. I can tell but not by how defensive he is, but the way he is defensive. I was a wolf last time, he's saying the same things I did last time.
I'm pretty suspicious of Mike, too, but I wouldn't take being defensive as a clue. What else are you supposed to do when you're being accused?
That being said, the stuff Jones' Girl said seems fairly solid, so he's definitely a possibility.
He suspected Mike, who we now know to be scum. Looks good to me, except for the first bit looks like he's
defending Mike. Odd.
Ju Ju Master wrote:
In case I get killed again, I'm gonna post this now
(quote pyramid)
STu's trying way too hard to act like a human, and a real human wouldn't need to do that. Unless there's some clues in the next story, I'd say STu's the most suspicious here.
It's true that Stu has been acting kind of weird all game, however I don't agree that he's trying too hard to act human. In fact, I think his actions point toward him being human. Here are some posts of his:
STupendous7 wrote:
I know the round has ended already, but I vote for Beyond the Grave, just because he's acting so suspicious.
"But DG, this looks totally scummy". Wait for it.
STupendous7 wrote:
Like I said above, at the beginning of the game I was just joking around. I thought since we weren't really starting the game yet, I could goof off some. I guess I was wrong then.
And in my last comment, the "Sweet we were right," I didn't really have anything else to say, so I just congratulated the other guys on getting another wolf. And, if we look at voting patterns, I voted for both Chris and JAU.
Probably I'm just incriminating myself by doing this, but if I don't say anything, it will be incriminating also.
Probably I'm on the way to death, but I don't really see how you all can kill me.
This is Stu's rebuttal to Ju Ju's posts above. Once again it looks like he's trying to defend his scummy actions. So Stu has spent the whole game going out of his way to make himself look human. Why don't I think this is scummy? I believe that if Stu were truly a wolf, the other wolves would have told him to knock it off when he did it early in the game. They'd show him how it's bad form to draw attention to yourself by asserting your humanity. Since he keeps doing it, I feel he is simply a very defensive human.
This in turn makes Ju Ju's latching onto him (which he has done several times) all the more suspicious. I think there is enough evidence here for me to
vote for Ju Ju.
Log in
Wiki
FAQ
Search
, why would you trust somebody who's so obviously a wolf - that clue Noid gave us can't be wrong, it's too obvious.