Homestar Runner Wiki Forum

Hmmm...yeah...SEAN'd! did get pretty defensive when accused...and he was one of the few to join the sbeenails bandwagon...

VOTE CHANGED to SEAN'd!!!

EDIT: TOTPD

_________________

1: I don't think you can change your vote like that
2: You should PM it to Toppy.

That's all. CONTINUE TELLING WHAT U THINK!

_________________

A day or two, eh topofsm? More like, a week or two. Has everybody voted?

_________________

Sorry guys that it took so long. I was in there and it was amazing, and sorry about the long wait again. Anyway, enough about my trip, let's get to business.

After the crowd decided on sb_enail.com to be executed, they took him to the local lake. "You see," said mayor topofsm, "If you are a mafia, you will be able to swim, if you can't swim, you are innocent." They tied him up and tied a ship's anchor to him along with a bunch of cinder blocks. And then they chucked him as far as he could go. He drowned. So yes. Sb_enail.com must be innocent.

You can't keep on doing this guys, you need to get the mafia.

I will now take votes from the mafias and detectives.

_________________
No, I lied. I'm never going to have a good sig. So just forget about it.

Grah...stupid mafia...

_________________

I'm not going to say "I told you so." Oh wait, I already did!

_________________

Erk.

At least we didn't kill the sheriff.

_________________

Well, you shouldn't have acted so suspicious Mr. "I'm not going to post at all!"

_________________

Gah, hath no mafias nor detectives decidedeth to PM me?

I have no PMs from either the mafias or the detectives. I would give names, but I can't.

_________________
No, I lied. I'm never going to have a good sig. So just forget about it.

Well, I think it's pretty obvious that none of the people who post their votes on the forum itself are Mafia or Detectives. Or they could be. Maybe they're trying to fool us. I chose to PM my votes rather than post. And I was busy with schoolwork.

_________________

I posted
Mafia post when you pm toppy

_________________

I don't think people have grasped the concept that mafia and detectives vote too. They do.

_________________
No, I lied. I'm never going to have a good sig. So just forget about it.

Okay, I'm ignoring that a certain detective hasn't PM'd me yet. Here we go again.

Exhibit A was walking in the park one day, maybe sipping on an iced tea or something like that, when he saw SEAN'D! quietly feeding the pigeon. He sat down on the bench and started talking until Somm-1 popped a squat next to them. They talked, until Exhibit A suddenly felt something inside of him, a rush of adrenaline! He immediately got up, and started running through the city. He felt so alive! He had so much energy! That was, until his conciousness mysteriously shorted and he fell over and collapsed and crashed on the sidewalk. His body was found floating in the local "Pet the dolphins" exhibit at the local children's aquarium the next morning.

Well, the mafia have struck again. What're you gonna do about it?

_________________
No, I lied. I'm never going to have a good sig. So just forget about it.

To me, that sounds more like Spiked iced tea'D!

We should thank the mafia. They just killed off a guy w/a homestar name reference. Now there's only four homestar people left. We have a 50/50 chance of gettng a mafia in that category!or we could get SEAN'D

_________________

I'ma bet The Cup of Coffee is a Mafia, he fits the whole H*R name thing and he hasn't really posted.

So yeah, I'm voting TCOC.

_________________

me too. He's been pretty suspicious lately!

_________________

I've been thinking something this entire game, and it's seeming more and more likely to me. What if Homerun Starrer is the mafia and he's been manipulating us! Think about it!



Here he's saying that he's at least played the game before, so he might know how to play well. The past experiance could also let him know how to think like a townsperson (meaning vote like he wasn't the mafia). Also, he's been the first to give an accusation/suspition every time so far!



Another interesting thing. Hi Guys hasn't posted at all either. Yet HS feels the need to exclude him from his search. Also in this post, we see more evidence of a lot of Mafia experiance.

One last thing. At his point, we have a 50/50 chance of eliminating a Homestar mafia. Any evidence at all only increases the odds for a correct choice.

So, instead of mindless conformity, which could cost us another wrong guess, let's think a little first. TELL WHAT U THINK!

_________________

Hmm.

It looks like you're trying a little too hard to single me out there, guy. And for the record, I forgot to mention HG.

And yes, I did say I like Mafia. I didn't say I was good at it.

If we keep pointing fingers at random people, we won't get anywhere.

_________________

We might!
That's been my tactic so far, anyway...

Rebuttle Hmm.

You have three distinct points in this. I will address all of them.

#1: I'm trying to single you out: I'm not going to argue that, it's perfectly true. The only reason I am is because I strongly suspect you're the mafia. "Too much"? Maybe. I just needed to see what evidence there was supporting my suspicions. I thought you could be the Mafia two rounds ago, so now I looked through this thread, and if I hadn't found any evidence at all, I wouldn't have said a word. But I did, and now here we are.

#2:You didn't say you were good at mafia: You didn't say that outright. You said that you had past experiance in Mafia. This could mean that you are an average player, but it could mean that you are a bit above average. Practice makes perfect. Right now, it seems you have a good grasp on what is suspicious and what is not. Thus, you could know how to be unsuspicious . I don't know how much you've played before, but it seems like you know a bit about how this works.

#3:We shouldn't randomly point fingers: Exactly! That is why I looked to see if you could be the mafia in the first place! I didn't just do this willy-nilly.

And three more points of my own:

#4:You haven't said anything about why you accuse people so quickly. Before you claim that I'm singling you out, try to explain why you keep doing it.

#5: We don't know if you honestly forgot Hi Guys. You could easily be lying on this one.

#6:Think about it this way. If we vote off HS, and he is the mafia, then we know that HG is also mafia. If he isn't, then TCOC and Douglas are most likely Mafia. We either take two turns to get a mafia, or one. It's up to you.

_________________

Hmm.

While you make a good point, you seem pretty eager to blame people, too.
I think if we fight amongnst eachother, we won't get anywhere. Now, I sort of think you may be a Mafia, but I have my doubts.
We shall see. For now, we should stick to people we have more hard evidence on.

_________________

I'm betting it's T-Coke. I'm really, really sure about this one, guys. Like, almost 100%.

For what it's worth (even though I'm dead), I would vote for Homerun also, not only for the points that have been already made, but for the fact that it seems that Homerun seems to be often voting before anyone else. My evidence isn't airtight, but if you look at one of the rounds where topofsm says who has voted, he says

This may make it appear that Homerun Starrer has voted last, but if we assume that topofsm simply read down his message list and added names, then he would have written the earliest message last, aka Homerun's. And who would pm first, before any formal discussion has taken place? A mafia member.

Edit: Also, Douglas, I'm not that surprised that you're agreeing with Homerun. According to my theory, you would have voted right after him. Perhaps because you're the second mafia?

Double Edit: Oh, and just for the ultimate told-ya'-so combo, I'll guess ikwaylx is the third mafia.

_________________
My Mario Kart DS Friend Code: 073074-162889!

I am neither confirming nor denying the fact that TCOC is mafia.

But, you need to keep in mind that you need to think of the detectives, and how you are endangering them. Remember the first round, both your doctors were killed in the same turn.

Now, what if TCOC is mafia and made you think not? What if I want you to vote for someone else? What if I am just messing with you?

Oh, and the mafia votes too, so appearing on the thread has nothing to do with it, unless you're Douglas.

_________________
No, I lied. I'm never going to have a good sig. So just forget about it.

You know what I think is going to happen again? We are probably going to vote off the first accused guy (this time it's TCOC) like every other round. And look how far that's got us.

HS, this is the first time I've seriously accused someone, while you have been doing it every round. I'm still waiting for some sort of explanation for that. And also, the only hard evidence we have on TCOC is that he doesn't post much. And you know that theory works. May I also note that we have exactly 7 rounds to kill a mafia or else we as townspeople lose. We need to get our head in the game. I'm alright with doing in TCOC, but if he isn't mafia, then you make a big jump up on the suspicious list. If I'm wrong, then I will probably make that jump.

Just remember, the clock is ticking.

_________________

And... about.... NOW! I'll say that 3 days is enough.

In the town hall. The Cup of Coffee has been voted off the town. But Susan piped up and said, "Where is he?" The truth was, he wasn't there. So they decided to find him. They also voted Hi Guys to kill him. Hi Guys agreed, and they stuck a gun on him. He went through town, ready to strike. In The Cup of Coffee's house, one lone light was on. He busted down the door and wasted the gun through the room. The problem was, he wasted it on a flight of stairs and the hallway to his house. He wasn't there. Hi Guys angrily threw down the gun. He walked up the creaky stairs cautiously into the bathroom. Nothing. His closet. Empty. His room. He and his girlfriend were kissing. Just as he took his shirt off, he saw The Cup of Coffee. "Don't interrupt!" He said. Hi Guys said, " You have been voted off." The Cup of Coffee jumped on him angrily, and tackled Hi Guys. Hi Guys immediately whacked him out of the room with his gun. The Cup of Coffee took his gun and punched him down the hall. Hi Guys ran to the stairs, but The Cup of Coffee tackled him. Hi Guys threw him off, down the stairs. The stairs buckled under his weight, and he landed inside a dark, secret, dungeon of sorts. When Hi Guys got down there, he saw him lying on a pointed waffle, dead. Upon further inspection, it appeared that he was completely innocent.

Start killing a mafia please!

Oh, and by the way, you lose.

_________________
No, I lied. I'm never going to have a good sig. So just forget about it.

Well, isn't this an interesting turn of events, eh, Homerun? Or should I say, Mafia?

_________________

Do what you like. We're already lost....

Jerky.

_________________

Dang. I was sure he was mafia... Oh well.

I don't even like jerky...

Yeah, sorry for being a bit harsh back there. I kind of got carried away. Um, what do you mean by "We're already lost?"

_________________