Homestar Runner Wiki Forum

I mean, a lot of people hate Marshie. I hate him, but not because he's creepy; just because he's annoying. There's even Nightmare Fuel about him. I don't find him that bad. What's so bad about Marshie?

_________________
GENERATION 23: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.
Check out my blog.
By the way, I'm Thy Not Dennis on the wiki.

I simply found him annoying. He doesn't scare me, period.

That's what I'm saying. Is there anyone who finds him creepy and/or nightmare-fuel-inducing?

_________________
GENERATION 23: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social experiment.
Check out my blog.
By the way, I'm Thy Not Dennis on the wiki.

Marshie is..... disturbing, but in no way scary. I mean, it'd be pretty hard to be scared of a cartoon marshmallow.

_________________
Using ridiculously elaborate schemes involving bone-curdling injuries to avoid spending time with family is the kind of Decemberween tradition I can get behind.

He creeps me out, but only in his voice and the stuff he says. Not scary, just wierd. I hate that frickin' marshmallow.

_________________
"Sid Hoffmann, or Sid Frenchman?" "Homestar, this is the dumbest game i've ever played" "Oh, come on! You're just bein' sore 'cause you're losin'" "Ok, i'll go with Sid Hoffmann." "Sid HoffFrenchman. Sorry, you lose, I said Sid Frenchman."

Like many of the supposedly "weird" things in the Homestar Runner universe, I don't think Marshie is nearly weird or creepy enough. He's just kinda boring as he is.

I like him.

_________________

''YOU CAN'T DESTROY ME"
"IM AN ABOMINATION! AND IM COMMING TO YOUR HOUSE AFTER SCHOOOL..!"
"Made from the best stuff...."
What Marshie says just disturbs me. He just seems like the creepy guy who sneaks into your house through the window and kidnapps you...

_________________
"He's got him in the half nelson! He's got him in the full nelson! OH NO! The dreaded Ozzie Nelson!!"

Kind of like DJ Lance Rock. Anyway, Marshie rules! It's been a long time since his last toon. I want to see him again. He's cooler that Crack Stuntman.

_________________
My mission is to destroy all baby show characters, and stop them from taking over the world.

He isn't a bad character or anything, but he gives me goosebumps whenever he says any of those lines.

_________________
"He's got him in the half nelson! He's got him in the full nelson! OH NO! The dreaded Ozzie Nelson!!"

His creepiest stuff is definitely in 8-Bit is Enough.
"I'll follow you everywhere!"
"Sometimes... after the game shuts down... I can hear him talking to me. He tells me to do things."
"ALL WORK AND NO FRUIT MAKES GEL-ARSHIE A DULL BOY!"

He's easily the Homestar Runner universe's creepiest, followed somewhat distantly by Coach Z and Senor Cardgage.

_________________

Crack Stuntman is awesome! Pistols for Pandas is one of my favorite shorts (and next epi-snowed is close second.)
I have not had nightmares about Marshie, but I think he is definitely terrifying. I think that if he came into my house, I would probably panic. I wasn't so sure about this, but then I heard his song, "Doin' the Wigglie."
"Ooooo! Doin' the Wigglie! Wiggle, waggle, wiggle, waggle, wiggle, waggle, go! Wiggle, waggle, wiggle, waggle, wiggle, waggle, go! I SAID GO! "
And the line of text does not do the creepiness justice.

_________________
"Maybe now that the HStarRwiki forums have killed off the best topic, everyone will go over to http://strongbadiathefree.forumotion.com/forum.htm so that I can get myself promoted!" -from Dangeresque 3.141592654: Uzi-Bazooka's Conquest

I think he's a pretty cool character, actually.
"Capital M, and then, arshie!"

And he doesn't creep me out as much as other characters like Coach Z and the Poopsmith.

_________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-FHzeTqMYfY
"I know someday you'll have a beautiful life, I know you will be a star in somebody else's sky, but why...why can't it be mine?" -Eddie Vedder

I love marshie, though i agree he is very very very very creepy

i tend to have a liking towards creepy characters

_________________
curse my lysdexia

I don't really like or hate marshie.
But the creepy stuff is what's so funny about marshie.
"You can't destroy me!" I mean that was funny.

_________________
"Register does not contain more than 50 doctors."
- Drive-Thru Whale

Lol @ The Shining reference.

_________________
"Strong Bad, I thought you said our float was going to be celebrating our nation's covered bridges!"
"No, I said it would be placing you in a fake snowman and hitting you with nunchucks... covered bridges..."

Check out my deviantART! http://bubblerevolution.deviantart.com/

Marshie himself isn't THAT bad, it's Gel-Arshie that's terrifying. Not only can you see his brain, but did you hear what he said? "I'M AN ABOMINATION!!! And I'm coming to your house after schoooool!"

_________________
One day I should probably put a picture here. Yup. I sure should.

I don't hate him, but he is kinda creepy.

_________________

I find Marshie hilarious. There's the "lonely, maladjusted middle-aged girls' sports coach" style of creepy that is Coach Z, there's the "burned-out, mentally vacant, shiftless hobo schemer" style of creepy that is Senor Cardgage, and there's the "unhinged psychopathic definitely-a-closet-serial-killer" style of creepy that is Fluffy Puff's mascot.

Why do you think we haven't seen Nibbler again?

_________________
Tiger, tiger, burning bright
In the forests of the night,
What immortal hand or eye
Dare frame thy fearful symmetry?

I never found Marshie to be creepy. Only one a few instances have I found him annoying but, he has had some funny lines.
"Hey guys wanna play some James?"

_________________
A comic book geek who loves to read comic books.

Um...two of your sentences contradict each other. First you say you hate him, then you say you don't find him that bad?

Anyway, i don't find Marshie so bad either. He's creepy, but in a sorta funny way. Like (even though the Coach is more than just "sorta" funny). Plus, Fluffy Puff Marshmallows sound delicious.

_________________
You're a girl.
Or maybe a wagon.
Filled up with pancakes.

Agreed.

After I heard that song in Baddest of the Bands, it scarred me for life...