PianoManGidley wrote:
The samples I got with the help of some friends, so they were free for me...>> They're quite good, though perhaps not QUITE worth their asking price (seems to be the main complaint of most folks--good quality samples, but still a bit too steep an asking price). I've got basically a full orchestra sans piano, with various articulations and dynamic ranges, as well as some effects such as glissandi and tremelos ("trembelos"

) and the like.
Yeah, the problem with commercial samples is that if you want high quality sample libraries, get ready to pay an arm for them.
I also listened to the songs you posted. Sounded very nice. Could've used more articulations with some instruments, but otherwise good.
I have the Silver edition of the East West/Quantum Leap Symphonic Orchestra ( There are Silver, Gold and Platinum editions available) over a year ago. It was pretty expensive yet it doesn't have that many features: too few articulations, only 16-bit samples (not that big of a gripe though), only close mic position samples (meaning the instruments lack the lovely recording environment/concert hall ambience) etc.
You can basically forget about authentic-sounding solo instruments and the notorious machine gun effect is there (meaning when you play a note quickly, it sounds all the same, no natural randomness), but most of the basic stuff are there.
To hear the EWQLSO Orchestra library in action, check out
this remix of Trogdor's Cave Theme that I did (I added some reverb to it).
Btw, I suggest checking out Peter Siedlaczek's Complete Classical Collection and String Essentials. Very natural sounding, especially the smart violins:
http://www.soundsonline.com/Complete-Cl ... S-399.htmlhttp://www.soundsonline.com/String-Esse ... S-396.htmlThere's also Sonic Implants, which sounds very good but costs big bucks:
http://www.timespace.com/sonic.aspPianoManGidley wrote:
About composing and music theory: theory is a great guide, but don't get too wrapped up in it unless you want to produce cookie-cutter works of stoicism. Don't allow man-made rules and observations to get in the way of the music that wants itself to be written.
Couldn't agree more with that. In the end, it's not some elaborate chord progression or clever use of articulations that your listeners are going to listen to. What simply sounds good is what matters. I've met people who've had no musical education and couldn't really play any instrument, yet they could compose absolutely stunning music.
If a song is beautifully (yet slavishly) composed according to rules and guidelines and sounds like crap, it's crap and that's it.
The problem with some mainstream pop music is indeed that it may have been produced by experienced top-notch producers with highly expensive studio equipment but the music itself is crap.